A proposed class action that accuses the world's three big DRAM makers of keeping memory scarce on purpose has cleared its first major hurdle. As Tom's Hardware reported on 15 November 2026, Judge Noël Wise of the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California denied the motion to dismiss filed by Micron, Samsung and SK hynix. The companies had argued the suit was a rerun of the 2018 antitrust case against them. The judge rejected that argument because the plaintiffs had put forward new evidence suggesting collusion.

Be clear about what this ruling is. It is not a judgment of guilt, and no court has found that the three companies colluded. Denying a motion to dismiss means the court found the case plausible enough to move forward. Both sides must still present their evidence and arguments before any decision. Even so, the case is worth following for anyone who buys boards with soldered-down LPDDR, because the memory market it concerns is the same one that maker-board vendors buy from.

Who is suing, and over what?

According to Hardware Busters' report on the complaint, the suit was filed on June 25 in the Northern District of California and assigned to Judge Wise. There are seventeen plaintiffs: 14 individual consumers and three small PC businesses. Named plaintiffs include Troy's Computers LLC and JB Tech Solutions LLC, which does business as My Florida PC. Tom's Hardware describes the group as 17 individuals and small businesses.

The complaint's central claim is that the three firms, which together control roughly 90 percent of the global DRAM market, conspired to keep commodity DRAM artificially scarce to inflate prices. In this telling, the industry's move toward high-bandwidth memory (HBM) for AI served as a pretext to wind down output of legacy formats, including DDR3 and DDR4. The complaint says commodity DRAM prices have climbed approximately 700 percent over a four-year span. It also argues that new competition cannot easily fix the problem, because building a DRAM fab costs between $15 billion and $20 billion and takes years.

The plaintiffs also point to downstream consumer harm. Hardware Busters notes that the complaint cites Apple's recent price increases on iPads and Macs, and Microsoft's Xbox price rises of $100 to $150.

The parallel moves alleged

In a concentrated market, competitors often behave alike, so plaintiffs have to offer more than similar behaviour to make collusion plausible. According to Tom's Hardware, the plaintiffs allege four parallel moves that restricted DRAM supply. The report names these among the events they cite:

  • Simultaneous production cuts. The plaintiffs cite "simultaneous DRAM production cuts" from October 2022 to April 2023, followed quickly by what they call a "coordinated pivot to HBM."
  • A DDR4 wind-down. The three companies announced the winding down of DDR4 production within a span of three months.
  • No capacity expansion. The plaintiffs say the companies failed to expand production capacity despite extraordinary prices, which jumped by as much as 500 percent in one year.

Tom's Hardware lists further factors the plaintiffs raise: stricter customer vetting during the shortage, a refusal to sign long-term DRAM contracts with customers, Micron's decision to shut down its consumer brand Crucial, multiple statements projecting the shortage, and the companies' involvement in previous price-fixing scandals.

The defendants' answer is that these are logical business moves to maximize revenue during a period of great demand, consistent with each company's own independent self-interest. They also say they behave similarly because they operate in a highly concentrated market and are all reacting to the same market pressures.

Judge Wise was not persuaded that this explanation ends the case at the pleading stage. The defendants had argued that they watch each other like hawks because competition is so tight. Tom's Hardware reports that the judge disagreed, writing: "Their contentions are more akin to hawks flying in formation — an activity that hawks ordinarily do not do."

Note the two different price figures. The 500 percent figure Tom's Hardware cites covers a one-year window. The roughly 700 percent figure in the complaint, as Hardware Busters reports it, covers four years. They measure different periods and are not necessarily in conflict.

What happens next

Tom's Hardware reports that the defendants have until December 7 to respond to the original complaint and that a case management conference, which will address administrative matters, is set for January 2027. The case is still a proposed class action. Hardware Busters says the plaintiffs are seeking class status, an injunction to end the alleged production squeeze, and treble damages under US antitrust law. Whether a class is certified is still undecided. No damages have been awarded, and none of the allegations has been proven. Micron has issued a statement disputing the allegations, saying it competes vigorously and fairly and in compliance with all applicable laws.

What It Means for Makers

The lawsuit will not change what a board costs this quarter. It does, however, put a legal spotlight on the same supply conditions that are now showing up in maker hardware prices.

The clearest recent example is Raspberry Pi. In a 2 November 2026 post, the company announced price rises for some 16GB products. It said a lack of alternative supply for 16GB DRAM, compounded by other ongoing component shortages, meant further increases on some of its highest-density products. The changes, as Raspberry Pi states them:

  • Raspberry Pi 5, 16GB: up $80, to $385 (as of 2 November 2026).
  • Compute Module 5, 16GB variants: up $40, with updated prices in the Compute Module 5 product brief.
  • Raspberry Pi 500+: price held.

Raspberry Pi's post does not mention the lawsuit, and nothing in the sources links its supplier situation to the alleged conduct. The company's own explanation is a supply problem: a lack of alternative supply for 16GB DRAM. That is consistent with the market structure the plaintiffs describe, though. When roughly 90 percent of global DRAM, by the complaint's account, comes from three firms, a board vendor that needs a particular density has few places to turn.

Raspberry Pi's practical advice is the most useful part for buyers: make sure you are not paying for more memory than you need. The company suggests lower-density variants or earlier Raspberry Pi models, or making memory optimisations in your applications. Before buying the top tier, it is worth measuring your workload's actual resident memory. The 16GB parts mainly make sense for workloads that truly use the memory, such as large local builds, heavy containers or memory-hungry inference.

For the small PC builders among PinoutFeed's readers, the plaintiff list is also worth a look. Three of the named plaintiffs are small PC businesses, and the complaint seeks to represent a broader class of consumers and businesses that bought products containing commodity DRAM during the price surge. If a class is eventually certified, the question of who counts as a purchaser will matter to businesses like those. Until then, the defendants' December 7 response and the January 2027 case management conference are the next dates to watch.

Sources